She's hiring a surrogate to...

19 min read3,715 words40 viewsPublished December 29, 2025

The late afternoon light in Olivia’s downtown loft was the kind she usually loved—long, golden, and forgiving—but today it felt like an interrogation lamp. It illuminated the single sheet of paper...

The late afternoon light in Olivia’s downtown loft was the kind she usually loved—long, golden, and forgiving—but today it felt like an interrogation lamp. It illuminated the single sheet of paper on her reclaimed oak dining table as if it were a sacred text, which, in a way, it was. The heading read: Surrogacy Agreement – Draft. Beside it sat a smaller stack: the profile of Eleanor Vance.

Olivia ran a hand through her chin-length dark hair, a nervous habit. At thirty-eight, with a thriving architecture firm bearing her name, she was accustomed to contracts, to blueprints, to building things from the ground up. But this… this was a blueprint for a person. For her child. Her eggs, harvested and frozen in a moment of pragmatic hope two years prior, waited in cryogenic storage. All she needed was the vessel, the sacred space. The surrogate.

She picked up Eleanor’s profile again. The photo showed a woman with a warm, open face, intelligent hazel eyes, and a smile that seemed to genuinely reach them. She was thirty, a freelance graphic designer, and her application letter was refreshingly devoid of cloying sentiment. I believe in building families, she had written, and I have the capacity to help someone build theirs. I approach this with respect, clear boundaries, and a commitment to the well-being of all involved. It was the ‘clear boundaries’ that had solidified Olivia’s choice. That, and the fact that Eleanor’s artistic sensibility, evident in her portfolio website, resonated with Olivia’s own.

The doorbell chimed, a soft, melodic tone. Olivia took a steadying breath, smoothed her linen shirt, and went to answer it.

Eleanor stood in the hallway, a canvas tote bag slung over her shoulder. She was taller than Olivia had anticipated, willowy where Olivia was compact and athletic. Her strawberry-blonde hair was pulled into a loose twist, a few strands escaping to frame her face. Up close, her warmth was palpable, a quiet energy that seemed to fill the stark, minimalist space of the loft entrance.

“Ms. March?” she asked, her voice a pleasant, mid-range alto.

“Olivia, please. Come in, Eleanor.”

“El, please,” she corrected with that same smile from the photo, stepping inside. Her eyes, those intelligent hazel eyes, swept the room, not with judgment, but with an artist’s appreciation. “Your space is incredible. The light is… everything.”

Olivia felt an unexpected flush of pleasure. “Thank you. It’s my design. Can I get you some tea? Water?”

“Tea would be lovely.”

Over chamomile in the living area, they navigated the strange dance of their meeting. They discussed the legal framework, the clinic’s protocols, the intended roles. Olivia would attend all major appointments. Eleanor would carry the pregnancy, adhering to medical advice. Communication would be regular but structured. The contract, drafted by Olivia’s lawyer, was thorough.

“It feels very… architectural,” Eleanor remarked, flipping gently through the pages, her fingers long and graceful.

Olivia blinked. “How so?”

“Precise. Load-bearing walls of clauses, contingency plans like emergency exits. Designed for stability.” She looked up, her gaze direct but not unkind. “I understand. You’re creating something permanent. You need the structure to be sound.”

No one had ever framed Olivia’s caution that way—as a necessary part of creation, not just fear. “Yes,” Olivia said, the word coming out softer than intended. “Exactly.”

They signed the preliminary documents a week later. The clinical process began with a detached, rhythmic efficiency. Hormone treatments for Eleanor to prepare her uterus. The thawing and fertilization of Olivia’s eggs with donor sperm. The transfer itself was a quiet, antiseptic affair in a dimly lit room. Olivia held Eleanor’s hand, a gesture that felt both contractual and profoundly intimate as they watched the tiny cluster of cells, a microscopic promise, disappear from the monitor on the wall and into Eleanor’s body.

For the two-week wait, Olivia fought the urge to check in constantly. She sent a simple text: Thinking of you. No need to reply. Eleanor responded with a sunset emoji. It was enough.

The call came on a rainy Tuesday. Eleanor’s voice was breathless, a mix of awe and professionalism. “Beta test is positive. The numbers are strong.”

Olivia sank into her desk chair, the world narrowing to the sound of rain against glass and the pulse in her ears. “That’s… thank you. How are you feeling?”

“A little surreal. But good. Really good.”

The first ultrasound was their second revolution around this new, shared sun. Olivia sat in a chair beside the exam table where Eleanor lay, gown draped over her knees. The room was cool, the gel slick. The technician moved the wand, and there, on the screen, was a flickering, rhythmic grain of light.

“There’s your baby’s heartbeat,” the technician said cheerfully.

Your baby. The words hung in the air. Olivia’s eyes were glued to that miraculous flutter. Then she looked at Eleanor. Eleanor’s head was turned toward the screen, her profile soft, her lips slightly parted. A single tear traced a path from the corner of her eye into her hairline. She wasn’t just a vessel, Olivia realized with a jolt. She was a witness. A guardian. And in that silent, dark room, lit only by the proof of life, the first load-bearing wall in Olivia’s carefully constructed blueprint quietly shifted.

The contractual coffee meetings evolved. They became weekly check-ins, then simply weekly meetings. They would talk about the pregnancy—the first flutter of quickening that Eleanor described as “like a goldfish swimming in chamomile tea,” the impending anatomy scan—but they also began to talk around it. Eleanor showed Olivia a branding project she was working on. Olivia brought blueprints for a new community center, seeking Eleanor’s eye for how the spaces would feel.

It was during the fifth month that Olivia first noticed the confusing undercurrent. They were at a small café, and Eleanor was explaining a client’s difficult feedback, her hands shaping the air as she spoke. The sun caught the fine, golden hairs on her forearm, and Olivia found herself following the line from her wrist to the rolled-up sleeve of her blouse, wondering what that skin would feel like under her fingertips. She shook her head, a minute, private gesture of dismissal. This is hormonal, she told herself. A transference of affection for the baby onto the carrier. It’s documented. It’s normal. But the thought felt hollow, a flimsy partition against a rising tide.

One afternoon in Olivia’s loft, now in the sixth month, Eleanor was admiring a structural model for a library. She leaned over the table, one hand unconsciously supporting the small, firm curve of her belly. Olivia found herself staring, not at the model, but at that protective gesture. A fierce, confusing wave of something—gratitude, protectiveness, a longing that had no clear target—washed over her.

“Would you… like to feel?” Eleanor asked quietly. She had caught Olivia’s gaze.

Olivia’s breath hitched. She had been waiting for an invitation, afraid to impose. Wordlessly, she nodded. Eleanor took her hand, her skin warm and slightly dry, and placed it gently on the side of her abdomen. They waited. For a moment, there was nothing but the warmth and the incredible tautness, the living curve of her. Then, a distinct, rolling push against Olivia’s palm. A foot? An elbow? A hello.

Olivia’s eyes flew to Eleanor’s. She saw her own awe reflected there, mixed with a quiet pride. Tears pricked Olivia’s eyes. This was her child. But it was moving inside Eleanor. The boundaries, so clear on paper, were dissolving in the reality of shared, miraculous biology.

“Hi,” Olivia whispered, to the baby, to Eleanor, to the universe.

Eleanor’s hand came to rest over Olivia’s, holding it there. “He’s active today.”

He. They didn’t know the sex yet, but Eleanor had taken to using the pronoun occasionally. Olivia found she liked it. She became aware of the heat of Eleanor’s hand layered over her own, a double seal. She should move. The moment was over. But she didn’t. She let her thumb stroke once, very lightly, over the cotton of Eleanor’s shirt. Eleanor’s breath caught, just a tiny catch, but Olivia heard it. She looked up and saw a flush spreading from Eleanor’s neck to her cheeks, her hazel eyes dark and unreadable. Olivia pulled her hand back as if scalded.

“I’m sorry,” she said, the words too formal, too sharp.

“Don’t be,” Eleanor said, her voice softer than usual. She turned back to the model, but her posture was different, a slight tension in her shoulders that hadn’t been there before.

The following week, Olivia invited Eleanor over to help choose paint samples for the nursery. The guest room was being emptied, a tangible step into the future. As they debated between “Whisper Gray” and “Celestial Blue,” Eleanor’s phone buzzed. She glanced at it, her expression shifting to mild annoyance.

“My sister,” she explained, silencing the call. “She’s… concerned.”

“About the pregnancy?” Olivia asked, lining up the paint chips on the floor.

“About… us. The arrangement.” Eleanor sat on the edge of the bare mattress, sighing. “She thinks I’m getting too attached. That the lines are blurring. She’s worried I’ll get hurt when it’s over.”

Olivia felt a cold knot form in her stomach. An external voice naming the very fear she carried. “And what do you think?” she asked, keeping her eyes on the paint chips.

Eleanor was quiet for a long moment. “I think,” she said slowly, each word considered, “that when you’re building something real, the lines aren’t always straight. They can blur. That doesn’t mean the structure is weak. It might mean it’s more… organic.” She looked at Olivia. “But it’s a risk. She’s not wrong about that.”

The admission hung between them, a shared acknowledgment of the uncharted territory they were in. “I don’t want you to get hurt,” Olivia said, the truth of it aching in her throat.

“I know,” Eleanor said. “But that’s not something you can clause into a contract, is it?”

They didn’t speak of it again, but the awareness thrummed between them, a new, live wire in the space they shared. Their meetings grew longer. Olivia found excuses to drop by Eleanor’s apartment with groceries or a book she thought she’d like. One evening, they cooked dinner together in Olivia’s kitchen, a simple pasta. Standing side by side at the island, their elbows brushing as they chopped herbs, Olivia was hyper-aware of every point of contact, every shared laugh, every time Eleanor’s shoulder leaned into hers for balance. It felt dangerously, wonderfully domestic.

The turning point came in the eighth month. Eleanor called, her voice strained. “I’m sorry to bother you. It’s probably nothing. Just some Braxton Hicks, but they’re… persistent. My doula suggested I get checked.”

“I’m on my way,” Olivia said, already grabbing her keys, her heart a frantic bird in her chest.

At the hospital, monitors were strapped to Eleanor’s belly, filling the room with the rapid, steady drum of the baby’s heartbeat. It was strong and reassuring. Eleanor, in a hospital gown, looked younger, vulnerable, her hair fanned out on the pillow. The contractions subsided with hydration and rest—a false alarm—but the doctor advised monitoring for a few hours.

“You should go home,” Eleanor said, embarrassed. “It’s late. I’m fine.”

“Don’t be ridiculous,” Olivia said, pulling a chair so close to the bed their knees almost touched. “I’m not leaving.”

She stayed. She fetched ice chips. She watched the monitors with the focus of a general surveying a battlefield. When the nurse left them in the dim quiet, the only sound was the heartbeat, a constant, shared rhythm. Olivia’s hand was on the bed rail, and without thinking, Eleanor reached out and covered it with her own. Her palm was cool. Olivia turned her hand over, threading their fingers together. It felt like the most natural thing in the world.

Eleanor broke the silence, her voice raspy. “You know, when I started this, I thought of it as a profound act of service. And it is. But I didn’t account for… you.”

Olivia stilled. “Me?”

“The way you look at the ultrasound pictures, like you’re memorizing starlight. The way you asked if I needed a new ergonomic chair for my home office, and then just bought it. The way you’re here now, looking like you want to fight the monitor for being too loud.” Eleanor’s voice was soft, raw with fatigue and something else, something tender and terrified. “You’re not just a client, Olivia. You’ve become my friend. Maybe my closest friend. And it’s… complicating my beautifully simple plan.”

The admission hung between them, fragile and true. Olivia squeezed her hand. “The contract didn’t have a clause for this.”

“No,” Eleanor agreed, her fingers tightening. “It didn’t.”

For Eleanor, the realization had been a slower, deeper current. It wasn’t one moment, but a hundred. The safe, professional fondness had begun to fissure the day Olivia brought her ginger candies after a mention of morning sickness, her brow furrowed with a concern that felt purely, personally for her, not just for the vessel. It had widened when she saw Olivia’s hands, usually so steady and precise, tremble as she cut the ribbon at the opening of her new community center, and Eleanor had felt a surge of pride so fierce it stole her breath. Lying in the hospital bed, feeling Olivia’s steadfast presence like a physical anchor, she knew the truth. The carefully maintained levees had broken. She was in love with the woman who was to be the mother of the child she carried. The symmetry of it was terrifying. The rightness of it was undeniable.

They didn’t speak of it again directly in the following days, but the space between them transformed, charged with a new, breathless potential. Olivia’s protective instincts, once channeled solely toward the abstract idea of her future child, now enveloped Eleanor with equal ferocity. She cooked meals that met Eleanor’s nutritional needs and whimsical cravings—pickles with almond butter, mango with chili salt. She drove her to appointments, her hand sometimes resting on the back of Eleanor’s seat, her fingertips just brushing the wool of her sweater, a ghost of a touch that made Eleanor shiver.

One evening, helping Eleanor organize the nursery in Olivia’s loft—the room now painted “Celestial Blue”—they found themselves surrounded by tiny clothes and unassembled furniture. Eleanor was trying to decipher an instruction manual for a crib, her brow furrowed in concentration. The sight of her, so profoundly there in the center of this room built for the future, her body heavy with the child they had made together, overwhelmed Olivia. A wave of love and fear crested within her, so powerful it was disorienting.

“El,” she said, her voice barely audible, a crack in her usual composure.

Eleanor looked up, the manual forgotten in her hands.

“I’m scared,” Olivia confessed, the admission shocking her as much as it seemed to shock Eleanor.

“Of the birth? Of being a mother?”

“Of this ending.” Olivia gestured between them, at the room, at Eleanor’s beautiful, round belly. “The baby comes, and you… you go back to your life. As per the contract. As per the plan.” She swallowed. “The thought of this loft without you in it… it feels like a design flaw I can’t fix.”

Eleanor put the manual down slowly. She walked over to Olivia, the gentle, rolling sway of her walk more pronounced. She stopped inches away. Olivia could smell her shampoo, a hint of citrus and ginger, and beneath it, the warm, unique scent of her skin. She could see the faint dusting of freckles across the bridge of her nose, the pulse fluttering in her throat.

“Who says that’s the plan anymore?” Eleanor whispered, her voice a husky thread of sound.

Olivia’s heart hammered against her ribs, a frantic counter-rhythm to the baby’s quiet movements. She searched Eleanor’s face, finding no joke, no artifice, only a hesitant, hopeful truth that mirrored her own. “What are you saying?”

“I’m saying the blueprint has changed,” Eleanor said, echoing their first meeting. She lifted a hand, her movements slow as if moving through water, and cupped Olivia’s cheek. Her palm was warm, her touch infinitely gentle. Her thumb stroked the high bone, a tactile question. “The foundation is the same. The child. But the structure… it wants to hold more. It wants to hold us.”

It was Olivia who closed the final, breathless distance. The kiss was not sudden or desperate, but a slow, inevitable convergence, like two rivers meeting after a long, winding journey. It tasted of relief, of homecoming, of a truth they had both been circling for months. Eleanor’s lips were soft, slightly chapped, and they yielded under Olivia’s with a soft sigh that vibrated through them both. Olivia felt the warm puff of Eleanor’s breath against her cheek, smelled the intimate, close scent of her. Olivia’s hands came to rest on Eleanor’s hips, feeling the solid, miraculous reality of her, the curve of her belly a firm, warm pressure against Olivia’s abdomen. One of Eleanor’s hands slid into Olivia’s hair, her fingers tangling gently at the nape of her neck, holding her close, while the other stayed cradling her face. The baby kicked then, a firm, insistent nudge right between them, a punctuation mark to the sentence they were writing with their bodies.

They broke apart, laughing softly, breathlessly, their foreheads touching. Olivia kept her eyes closed, savoring the feel of Eleanor’s skin against hers, the lingering sweetness on her lips, the way her whole body seemed to hum with a new, right frequency.

“He approves,” Eleanor murmured, her voice thick with emotion.

“I love you,” Olivia said, the words leaving her as naturally as breathing, a truth finally given its name. “I think I have for a while.”

Eleanor kissed her again, a softer, sealing promise. Her lips were tender, lingering. “I love you, too.” She said it like a revelation, like a cornerstone being laid.

The final month was a cocoon of intimate anticipation. They moved Eleanor’s things into the loft, not as a guest, but as a resident. The contract was amended, notarized, and filed away in a drawer, replaced by whispered conversations in the dark and hands learning new geographies—of skin stretched taut and luminous, of skin yearning for touch. Their intimacy was a careful, sensual exploration, full of reverence for Eleanor’s changing body and the new, breathtaking vulnerability between them. It was kisses that lingered over breakfast, embraces that spoke of permanence as they swayed together to no music, nights spent curled together on the sofa, Olivia’s hand resting on Eleanor’s belly, feeling their son dance as they dreamed aloud of his future, their voices low and intertwined.

Leo was born on a bright spring morning after a long, intense labor. Olivia never left Eleanor’s side, holding her, urging her on, her own tears falling when Eleanor’s did, her lips pressed to Eleanor’s sweaty temple, whispering, “You are amazing, you are powerful, I love you,” like a mantra. When Leo was placed, squalling and perfect, on Eleanor’s chest, the world stopped. Then the nurse, gently, lifted him and placed him in Olivia’s waiting arms.

She looked down at this tiny, red-faced being, her son, her heart splitting and expanding in a single, seismic moment. Then she looked at Eleanor, exhausted, radiant, her face streaked with tears and sweat, watching them with an expression of utter, boundless love. Olivia brought Leo close, breathing in his newborn scent, then bent to place him carefully back on Eleanor’s chest, her own body curving around them both, her arms encircling them. A family, not by blueprint, but by the beautiful, unpredictable architecture of the heart.

The first months were a blur of sleepless nights and overwhelming joy. They moved through it as a unit, a triad. Eleanor breastfed, and Olivia would take the baby afterward, rocking him while Eleanor slept, her love for the woman who had given her this gift a tangible thing in the quiet dark, as solid as the floor beneath her feet.

One evening, when Leo was three months old, they were on the large sofa, the city lights twinkling outside the floor-to-ceiling windows like a scattered blueprint of another life. Leo was asleep on Eleanor’s chest, having just finished nursing, his lips still making soft, sucking motions. Olivia sat close, her arm around Eleanor’s shoulders, her fingers gently stroking Leo’s downy head.

Eleanor leaned into her, sighing contentedly. “Remember the first meeting? That piece of paper on your table?”

“The architectural stability,” Olivia said with a soft smile, her lips brushing Eleanor’s hair.

“I was wrong,” Eleanor murmured, her eyes on their son’s peaceful face. “It wasn’t the contract that was the architecture.” She shifted slightly, wincing at a sore muscle, and Olivia’s hand immediately moved to massage her lower back, the touch instinctive, proprietary. Eleanor smiled, leaning into the pressure. “It was us. We’re the structure. All three of us. The living part. The part that settles and creaks and holds everything up.”

Olivia pressed a kiss to Eleanor’s temple, breathing in the scent of her, of milk, of baby, of home. The loft, once a monument to solitary achievement, was now filled with the soft, vital sounds of their shared life—the hum of a dishwasher, the rustle of a blanket, the rhythmic breath of their sleeping child, the low murmur of the news on the television.

Later, after they had put Leo to bed in the celestial blue room, Olivia went to her office to retrieve a file. Her eyes fell on the drawer where the amended surrogacy agreement rested, filed away under ‘L’ for Leo, for love, for a life unplanned. She didn’t open it. She didn’t need to. She looked through the open door to the living room, where Eleanor was folding a tiny onesie, her brow slightly furrowed in concentration, a song humming under her breath. The clean, precise lines of the contract had promised a child, a transaction, an end date. What lived here now, in the warm, messy light of this evening, was something no clause could ever capture: a love that had been built room by room, heartbeat by heartbeat, a sanctuary far more beautiful and resilient than any blueprint could have ever designed.

Create Your Own Story

Enjoyed this story? Generate your own personalized story with our AI writer.

More Lesbian Stories